Grading the American Idol Season Seven Top 8 Girls On The TiVo Multi-Bloop Scale

I finally figured out why the Girls are so much harder to sit through than the Guys: they’re not nearly as creative. They play the competition to safe. On 80’s Night, with so many crazy awesome songs to choose from (Madonna to The Bangles to Tiffany and on and on), how come there were still four turn the volume down ballads? Where was the invention? Brooke White turning Pat Benatar into a ... (link)